TradeDay vs Lucid Trading: the rules compared
TradeDay and Lucid Trading differ most in drawdown type, daily loss limit and evaluation fee. TradeDay offers end-of-day and intraday drawdowns, while Lucid Trading uses an end-of-day drawdown on every plan. TradeDay sets no daily loss limit in its evaluations, while Lucid Trading sets a daily loss limit on every evaluation ($600 to $2,700).
The verdicts at 50K
Cheaper to start
TradeDay$79 against $90.20 to reach a funded account.
Runs your bot
Both allow automated trading, with conditions.
Each firm’s 50K plan whose rules treat a trader with no edge best, or its least expensive when none is simulated.
9 rules differ
- Price$79 a month$90.20 once
- Reset$79$90
- Daily loss limitNo daily loss limit$1,200
- Best day, evaluation30%50%
- Minimum days5 trading daysNo minimum
- Contracts5 contracts4 contracts
- First payout1 trading day5 trading days and 5 winning days of $150 or more
- Largest payoutNo cap$2,000
- Profit split50%90%
Plans on record
TradeDay sells 12 plans from 25K to 150K, while Lucid Trading sells 16 plans from 25K to 150K.
Evaluation fee
TradeDay charges $45 to $265 a month, while Lucid Trading charges $50.30 to $585.20 once.
Billing
TradeDay bills its evaluations monthly until they are passed, while Lucid Trading charges its evaluations once.
Drawdown type
TradeDay offers end-of-day and intraday drawdowns, while Lucid Trading uses an end-of-day drawdown on every plan.
Daily loss limit
TradeDay sets no daily loss limit in its evaluations, while Lucid Trading sets a daily loss limit on every evaluation ($600 to $2,700).
Consistency
TradeDay caps the evaluation's best day at 30% to 45% of the profit, while Lucid Trading caps the evaluation's best day at 50% of the profit on 8 of 12 plans.
Minimum trading days
TradeDay asks for at least 3 to 5 trading days, while Lucid Trading has no minimum number of trading days.
First payout
TradeDay pays a first payout after 1 to 5 trading days, depending on the size, while Lucid Trading pays a first payout after 0 to 5 trading days, depending on the size.
Profit split
TradeDay pays a 50% to 80% profit split, while Lucid Trading pays a 90% profit split.
What they share
- Activation fee: None
- Funded accounts at once: Up to 5
- Automated trading: Allowed with conditions
TradeDay: Allowed with conditions
TradeDay allows automated and algorithmic trading with conditions. Your own automated system may run on NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Jigsaw or Quantower; third-party bots, API access and identical trades across users are banned.
Checked 21 Oct 2026 · Source: tradeday.freshdesk.com
Lucid Trading: Allowed with conditions
Lucid Trading allows automated and algorithmic trading with conditions. Bots and trade copiers are permitted on evaluation and funded accounts if they follow every Lucid rule; high frequency trading and microscalping are banned and the trader bears every software error.
Checked 21 Oct 2026 · Source: support.lucidtrading.com
TradeDay and Lucid Trading, topic by topic across each firm’s plans on saleShowHide
| Topic | TradeDay | Lucid Trading |
|---|---|---|
| Plans on record | 12 plans, 25K to 150K | 16 plans, 25K to 150K |
| Evaluation fee | $45 to $265 a month | $50.30 to $585.20 once |
| Billing | Billed monthly until passed | Paid once |
| Activation fee | None | None |
| Drawdown type | End of day and intraday | End of day on every plan |
| Daily loss limit | None in the evaluation | $600 to $2,700 on every evaluation |
| Consistency | Best day at most 30% to 45% | Best day at most 50% (4 with none) |
| Minimum trading days | 3 to 5 trading days | No minimum |
| First payout | After 1 to 5 trading days, depending on the size | After 0 to 5 trading days, depending on the size |
| Profit split | 50% to 80% | 90% |
| Funded accounts at once | Up to 5 | Up to 5 |
| Automated trading | Allowed with conditions | Allowed with conditions |
25K
- TradeDay QP Intraday 25K$45 a month, $1,000, intraday
- TradeDay QP EOD 25K$54 a month, $1,000, end of day
- TradeDay Fast Pass 25K$65 a month, $1,000, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidPro 25K$70.60 once, $1,000, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidFlex 25K$50.30 once, $1,000, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidDaily 25K$65.10 once, $1,000, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidDirect 25K$230.30 once, $1,000, end of day
50K
- TradeDay Fast Pass 50K$95 a month, $2,000, end of day
- TradeDay QP Intraday 50K$59 a month, $2,000, intraday
- TradeDay QP EOD 50K$79 a month, $2,000, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidPro 50K$115.40 once, $2,000, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidFlex 50K$90.20 once, $2,000, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidDaily 50K$95.20 once, $2,000, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidDirect 50K$360.50 once, $2,000, end of day
100K
- TradeDay Fast Pass 100K$175 a month, $3,000, end of day
- TradeDay QP Intraday 100K$108 a month, $3,000, intraday
- TradeDay QP EOD 100K$129 a month, $3,000, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidPro 100K$180.40 once, $3,000, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidFlex 100K$170.60 once, $3,000, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidDaily 100K$155.40 once, $3,000, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidDirect 100K$490 once, $3,500, end of day
150K
- TradeDay Fast Pass 150K$265 a month, $4,500, end of day
- TradeDay QP Intraday 150K$162 a month, $4,500, intraday
- TradeDay QP EOD 150K$180 a month, $4,500, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidPro 150K$245.50 once, $4,500, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidFlex 150K$250.40 once, $4,500, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidDaily 150K$220.50 once, $4,500, end of day
- Lucid Trading LucidDirect 150K$585.20 once, $5,000, end of day
TradeDay or Lucid Trading?
At 50K, the TradeDay QP Intraday 50K costs $59 to fund on a first attempt and the Lucid Trading LucidFlex 50K $90.20.
TradeDay offers end-of-day and intraday drawdowns, while Lucid Trading uses an end-of-day drawdown on every plan. TradeDay sets no daily loss limit in its evaluations, while Lucid Trading sets a daily loss limit on every evaluation ($600 to $2,700). TradeDay charges $45 to $265 a month, while Lucid Trading charges $50.30 to $585.20 once. TradeDay bills its evaluations monthly until they are passed, while Lucid Trading charges its evaluations once. TradeDay caps the evaluation's best day at 30% to 45% of the profit, while Lucid Trading caps the evaluation's best day at 50% of the profit on 8 of 12 plans. TradeDay pays a first payout after 1 to 5 trading days, depending on the size, while Lucid Trading pays a first payout after 0 to 5 trading days, depending on the size. TradeDay pays a 50% to 80% profit split, while Lucid Trading pays a 90% profit split. TradeDay asks for at least 3 to 5 trading days, while Lucid Trading has no minimum number of trading days.
On a first attempt with no reset, the TradeDay QP Intraday 50K costs $59 ($59 evaluation (1 month)) against $90.20 for the Lucid Trading LucidFlex 50K ($90.20 evaluation). Resets and extra months can change the order.
TradeDay allows automated and algorithmic trading with conditions. Your own automated system may run on NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Jigsaw or Quantower; third-party bots, API access and identical trades across users are banned. Lucid Trading allows automated and algorithmic trading with conditions. Bots and trade copiers are permitted on evaluation and funded accounts if they follow every Lucid rule; high frequency trading and microscalping are banned and the trader bears every software error.
- Topstep vs TradeDay
- Topstep vs Lucid Trading
- Apex vs TradeDay
- Apex vs Lucid Trading
- My Funded Futures vs TradeDay
- My Funded Futures vs Lucid Trading
- Tradeify vs TradeDay
- Tradeify vs Lucid Trading
- TradeDay vs Take Profit Trader
- TradeDay vs Alpha Futures
- TradeDay vs Bulenox
- TradeDay vs Earn2Trade
- TradeDay vs FundedNext Futures
- Take Profit Trader vs Lucid Trading
- Alpha Futures vs Lucid Trading
- Bulenox vs Lucid Trading
- Earn2Trade vs Lucid Trading
- FundedNext Futures vs Lucid Trading
Replay of trade 1210 from an AlgoLift engine backtest of a research strategy on NQ, 13 February 2025: real bars, the trade still open.
Simulated results. They have inherent limitations. Read the full statementHide the statement
These results are based on simulated or hypothetical performance results that have certain inherent limitations. Unlike the results shown in an actual performance record, these results do not represent actual trading. Also, because these trades have not actually been executed, these results may have under-or over-compensated for the impact, if any, of certain market factors, such as lack of liquidity. Simulated or hypothetical trading programs in general are also subject to the fact that they are designed with the benefit of hindsight. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to these being shown.
Test yours
Run your strategy through both rulebooks at once.
One backtest, both accounts, every rule, before you pay either fee.
- 1Describe it to Algo, or build it yourself
- 2Backtest it on years of real futures data
- 3Replay every trade under your firm's rules
Rules checked against the firms’ own pages, most recently on 21 October 2026. This is a summary of each firm’s published rules, not financial advice and not a recommendation of any firm. Firms change their rules and prices; read the firm’s own page before you buy. Facts are paraphrased and linked to their source. Firm names are used only to say which firm a rule belongs to; they belong to their owners, and AlgoLift is not affiliated with or endorsed by any firm.